Trick or Treat! Where the Goddess and Church Collide

Halloween seems such a secular holiday with allbonfire on a hill and all the Celtic tribes
those ghouls and goblins going door to door withextinguished the fires in their homes and traveled
their never-ending extortion scheme called "trickto the bonfire to relight their fires from a
or treat". It is hard to imagine that this traditioncommon source, signifying their unity and
rose from a mixture of pagan and Christianattempting to bring good fortune to their
religious practices that reach back into antiquity.households. It was an occasion for spiritual ritual
Tricks or Treatsas well as celebration and the sharing of the
Trick or Treating has its roots in the myths ofharvest.
Hecate, the Greek goddess of the crossroads. AJack O'Lanterns
quiet and compassionate goddess, Hecate wasAccording to folklore, Irish farmers carved little
responsible for helping travelers find their way tolanterns out of turnips to carry their new flames
their eventual destinations.lit from the Samhain bonfire back to their homes.
Nocturnal Wanderings on Autumn NightsThe belief that the flames would flicker to give
One of Hecate's duties was to ease the transitionwarning when spirits were present led to the
of the dying and, after their deaths, to help themtradition of carving faces into them to help scare
become adjust to their new homes in thethe spirits away.
Underworld. In her role as 'Queen of the Night',Centuries later, during the great potato famine in
she sometimes took those who were restlessIreland, Irish immigrants brought his custom with
and finding it difficult to "settle in" on brief tripsthem, but it was quickly changed to carving
back to the land of the living--just to help thempumpkins since they were more plentiful and
gradually adjust to the change.certainly easier to carve!
Mid-autumn was the time of year when the "veilOf Saints and Souls
between the worlds" was thought to be theDuring the Roman occupation of the Celtic regions
thinnest and most easily penetrated, a time whenin the first century A.D. a new Christian holiday,
the laws of space and time were temporarily"All Hallows Day", was introduced by the Roman
suspended, allowing the spirit world to intermingleCatholic Church. It incorporated many of the
with the living.pagan Samhain customs, for it had long been the
Often seen traipsing around the countryside withpractice of the Roman church to co-opt some of
her following of ghosts, Hecate was both honoredthe religious practices of local religions in order to
and feared. Understandably, the stories of theseease the practitioners into the Christian religion by
wanderings stimulated phobias about becomingmaking it seem more familiar.
''possessed' by one of the spirits who might haveThe word Halloween actually came from
been searching for a body to occupy!contraction of the word "All Hallows Eve" which
Treats to Eatoccurred on the same date as Samhain. Also
Gifts of food and drink were left on the doorstepknown as "All Souls (or All Saints) Day", the
at night to "feed" the wandering spirits andholiday was celebrated in remembrance of the
prevent their coming into the house looking forSaints and other beloved departed on the first of
food. (Presumably vagrants, the homeless,November.
escaped slaves, and wandering dogs were theTricks Or Treats: Your Choice Entirely
actual beneficiaries of this practice. Perhaps thisOn All Hallows Eve, beggars were allowed to
practice accounts for why Hecate was consideredcome to the doors and ask for "All-Souls Cakes"
the protectress of the outcast and the(currant-filled biscuits or scones). In return the
oppressed.)beggars promised to pay for their treats by
And thus the tradition of "treating" began. Thesaying prayers for the recently deceased of the
presence of ghosts, skeletons, and demons onhousehold. If the household was stingy, vandalism
our porches should hardly surprise us!often ensued--hence, the association between
Halloween and the Autumn HarvestTricks and Treats.
In ancient Ireland, October 31 marked the officialTrick or treating in the true spirit of Halloween
"end of summer". It was time for the paganasks us to be more understanding of those who
festival of Samhain, a chance to get together andin some way seem "different" from us, perhaps
relax after the completion of the final harvest.even frightening. Given the meaning of the ancient
Any crops that had not yet been harvested werecustoms, Halloween should also remind us to
to be left in the fields to feed the spirits and keepshare our bountiful gifts and to take a moment to
them at bay.recall and honor "those who have gone on before
During Samhain, the Druids created an enormousus".